Our Menu

​​Fire Island Bowls 
All island bowls are served with your choice of rice or noodles, sautéed vegetables,

and your choice of protein. Customizing your meal is as easy as 1-2-3!

1. Choose Your Rice or Noodles
White Rice 
Brown Rice 
Island Rice 
Island Noodles 

2. Choose Your Protein
All Island Veggies
Char-Grilled Chicken
Luau Pulled Pork
Chicken/Steak Combo
Char-Grilled Steak
Blackened Shrimp

3. Choose Your Flavor
Pineapple Teriyaki – Sweet, with hints of ginger & pineapple  
Lava Flow Peanut – Medium heat, exploding with flavor 
Spicy Orange – Fresh, clean, and tangy  
 Fire Island Teriyaki – Spiced up a bit  

**Add Extra Protein to any meal for an additional charge 

Tropical Chicken Salads 
Hand tossed, with made-from-scratch dressings. (You should try them all!) 

Volcano Chicken Salad – Our most popular salad. Lettuce, tomatoes, Gorgonzola cheese, 
                                toasted pita bread  & sesame ginger vinaigrette dressing.
Blazing Chicken Caesar Salad –Lettuce with croutons, Asiago cheese, toasted pita bread
             & lightly spicy Caesar dressing
Mango-Passion Chicken Salad –Lettuce, mango, Gorgonzola cheese, red peppers, Bermuda 
                                                                        onions, toasted pita bread & sweet mango-passion vinaigrette dressing.
Ranch Chicken Salad - Lettuce, tomatoes, corn relish, black beans, red peppers, Bermuda 
                                                                       onions, shredded pepper jack cheese, toasted pita bread, & Fire Island Ranch dressing

**Substitute Steak or Shrimp for an additional cost

Chef ‘s Specials 

Chili Lime Tilapia –Llawai’a Punahele  (fisherman’s Favorite)
Served with your choice of rice, Pineapple Mango Salsa & a half size Volcano Salad

Island Platters 
Served with rice or noodles, sautéed vegetables & tropical macaroni salad 
(50% more than our bowls)

Big Kahuna Chicken – Ride the big one
Luau Pulled Pork - Slow roasted tenderness 
Steak and Chicken – Two great flavors
Char-Grilled Steak – Great island flavor
Blackened Shrimp – Sautéed to perfection
Surf & Turf – Surf rider favorite

North Shore Pipeline Sandwiches 
Served with your choice of creamy Tropical Macaroni Salad, Cole slaw, or Chips. 

Pineapple Chicken Sandwich – Spicy mayo, 2 pineapple slices, pepper jack cheese, le tomatoes, Bermuda onion, & Teriyaki sauce
Luau Pulled Pork Sandwich – Spicy Mayo, slaw, 2 pineapple slices, & Teriyaki sauce
Char-Grilled Steak Sandwich – Spicy mayo, lettuce, tomato, Bermuda onions, pepper jack cheese & Teriyaki sauce
Chili Lime Tilapia Sandwich – Spicy Mayo, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, & tomato

Small Islander’s Meals
Half-sized meals that include a beverage for children under 12 

Pineapple Teriyaki Bowl – Grilled chicken & fresh vegetables with your choice of rice or noodles  
Macaroni and Cheese – A kid’s sized favorite!  


Salted Carmel or Chocolate Chunk Cookie

(Phone-in orders welcome) Or order online at www.fireislandgrill.com
Catering & Fundraising Available